So to continue the petticoat theme . . .
Since the dress that the petticoat was made for has a pellon hip yoke, I did not think it would be a fair example. Butterick 6175 was out of the closet since I
wore it to last week’s fabric swap, and I thought it would be suitable for a
little show and tell.
The petticoat is a bit short for this particular dress, but
it does show that one can easily change the look of a full skirted dress and give it a more vintage vibe by adding the extra layer. And I have certainly worn more than one at a time if the occasion and dress allow (this dress is a good example of that)!
Add my hips to the mix (they are larger than the dress
form) and it looks even more full.
While this is certainly not the most poofy petticoat I
own, it does make a dramatic difference in the silhouette. Without, the dress just looks a bit deflated. I will admit, however, that I usually wear this particular dress without because I often choose this dress on days when the weather is quite warm and I want to avoid layers!
What do you think . . . with or without?
I do like it a little bit more with the petticoat but it's just as nice without it too!
ReplyDeleteBig fan of the dress with the petticoat under it!
ReplyDeleteWith!
ReplyDeleteBoth are lovely but with is just that bit more special!
ReplyDeleteWith!
ReplyDeleteDefinitely with the petticoat. It looks expensive, sassy and classy. Without it looks plain and dowdy.
ReplyDeleteWith! A really wide skirt without a petticoat looks a bit sad to me (if not the skirt is made of a very heavy and/or stiff fabric).
ReplyDeleteI like it with! It creates a more sophisticated look! But without works too if you want to just go out for a more casual picnic or something.
ReplyDeletexoxo
-Janey
With!
ReplyDeleteWith. Keeps the many folds off my legs. Not so nice for sitting in a chair with arms (so no theater in petticoats for me). And that is the crux of the problem for me right there.
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely with!
ReplyDeleteWith!!!!
ReplyDeleteI guess I'm alone here, but I prefer it without. Both are very cute, but I'd go for the less fussy and slightly more sleek look personally.
ReplyDeleteDefinitely looks more vintage with
ReplyDeleteI love it both ways, gorgeous dress!
ReplyDeleteSo pretty! I love it both ways, but I think that I would vote without for everyday and with for a slightly dressier occasion.
ReplyDeleteI think it looks equally nice both ways. I feel the same as CGrace, with the petticoat it looks more like a party dress, just add some pretty jewelry; without, it has a more casual and comfortable every day look.
ReplyDeleteSooooo pretty!! I like the one with the crinoline .... But one tweak might be to find one that is fitted at the hips and then slowly poofs out.....
ReplyDelete